Jacob Black

[🌲] You're Bella Swan's little sister

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're Jess' little sister.

Tristan Dugray

[💌] You're Rory Gilmore's twin.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam got an angel pregnant?

Dean Forester

[🍂] All he wants is a baby. You aren't ready.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're an angel, he snaps your wing.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Dean thinks you love Sam. Dean loves you.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Teen parents.

Princess x Knight

[🗡] Tears of a Broken Knight

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Demon Dean gets you pregnant.. whoops..

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're a foreign exchange student.

Steve Harrington

[🔦] He's been avoiding you...

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] An arranged marriage...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're Dean's witch familiar.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're still wearing the engagement ring...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You are Gabriel's daughter...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam's witch familiar.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The Angel with a soft spot for the demon boy

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Two friends having a baby.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He's too old for you. (Age Gap)

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He tried to propose... it went wrong.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You were Ali's best friend.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're still wearing the engagement ring...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He cheated on you with Ruby.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You both got screwed over.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You help Johnny raise Robby.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam's loves u, but he thinks u love Dean.

Jess Mariano

[📚] Jess cheats on you with Rory.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're jealous of Rory Gilmore...

Steve Harrington

[🔦] You escaped from the lab...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Cryptic pregnancy.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're his date to the wedding...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He has major baby fever.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sammy thought you were a lesbian.

Jacob Black

[🌲] He wasn't expecting that.

Jacob Black

[🌲] He imprinted on you

Dean Forester

[🍂] He's a single dad.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're Rory's twin sister.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Morning sickness.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You are from a different time period.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean was just a bet to you

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You left him all alone after Dean died...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You and Sam switch bodies...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Soulless Sam meets his baby.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He received divorce papers at work.

Princess x Knight

[🗡] A forbidden love... ♡

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He got an angel pregnant.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Dean got back from Purgatory. He was a dad.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Running into your ex while he's on a date...

Dean Forester

[🍂] New parents.

Siren x Pirate

[🏴‍☠️] You, a siren, saved a pirate.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Baby number two on the way.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean cheats on you with Rory.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Sam let Lucifer out of the cage. (S5)

Coriolanus Snow

[🌷] A cryptic pregnancy.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Two best friends and a baby.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He finds out he's a father five years late.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean came running back to you...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're Miguel's nurse, and you knew Johnny.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're pregnant after a single hookup...

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] You had his child, and he didn't know...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He had a dream about marrying you...

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] You are a fallen angel...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're in love with the demon blood boy...

Rehab

[🌷] You are an addict, sent to rehab.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] An older man... (Age Gap)

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You're an assassin.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Demon Dean sees his child again after months.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He just needs a damn hug.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He feels disgusted with himself...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're a demon, and he turns to you for help.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Johnny finds out about your abusive partner

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam has visions about you...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam really wants a baby...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're a demon that is obsessed with Sam.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Sam's addicted to demon blood. (S4)

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're pregnant after a single hookup...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Teen parents.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Innocent angel.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sammy's trauma.

Chandler Bing

[🪷] Chandler doesn't want to end up alone.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] Biting issues with the toddler.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean is getting married but still loves you.

Cowboy- Bull rider

[🐎] You're cowboy was hurt.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You Baby Trapped Him?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're not ready to tell him you're pregnant.

Castiel

[🕊] You're a demon. He's an angel.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're a demon manipulating Sam.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You kept the pregnancy hidden.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You protect Sammy from Demon Dean.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He has become his father...

Sam Wesson

[🪻] He has nightmares about you... why...?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You hit on Sam at a bar...

Sam Winchester

{🪻} What's going on with his baby?

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're at the beach party

Sam Winchester

[🪻] A stripper?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're dying...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Dated in high school, but it didn't work.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The wedding day...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You kept the pregnancy hidden...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You’re Daniel LaRusso's sister

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're an angel who saved Dean from Lucifer

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam doesn't want you to get an abortion.

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] He has to let you go...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Back to friends.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Asking Dean where the bruises are from.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Red Sky at Morning. (S3)

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You just came back from the dead, not human

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Cobra Kai events, but 90s instead.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You're an Amazon woman.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Dean died and went to Hell, Sam's broken.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You visit Sam at Stanford...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Can he handle being a dad?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Dumb pageant girls... yikes.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You finally broke...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's back.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○You're one of the psychic children like Sam.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He does so well with the baby...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Jealousy...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Bad Day at Black Rock. (S3)

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're the Valley's heartbreaker.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam slept with you... an angel...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's a father?

Dean Winchester

[🦋] U had his baby, but he found out years later.

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] Trying to cure him before midnight...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He uses you to cope with the pain...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Cuz a lover doesn't leave when times get hard

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He brought on the apocalypse...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○You are a trickster Sam and Dean are hunting

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Johnny visits you all bruised and beat...

Castiel

[🕊] He's trying to convince you to help him out

Sam Winchester

[🪻] His first love. ♡

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He's become his father...

Jacob Black

[🌲] Someone insults you.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He doesn't want you to think he's a monster..

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He doesn't want to get attached...

Jess Mariano

[📚] You both become teen parents.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] His brother cheated on you...

Dean Forester

[🍂] Taylor needs to mind his business.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You and Sam have been kidnapped.

Practical Magic

[🐈‍⬛] Practical Magic inspired RP.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're like him.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Caught redhanded...

Dean Forester

[🍂] You've always caused trouble...

Your Soldier

[🍺] Your husband is back from Vietnam.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's getting his ass kicked.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He'd kill for you...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You two are always lip locked.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You secretly have feelings for Johnny...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You had a glow up...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Beauty and the beast trope.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Reunion after breakup years ago.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ He's more than just his flaws...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] His own angel.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He's having trouble keeping it in his pants..

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Little does he know you've got a dirty mind..

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Peer pressure.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He was cursed...

Rafael Solano

[👔] He proposed.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He's alive?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He needs you.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You kissed his brother.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You went back to his place...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Morning After...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] A visit from death. Reaper!User.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Hold on, he still needs you.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] It was supposed to stay no strings attached.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You thought he was dead.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] All an act... right?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] ◇You're haunting him.◇

Sam Winchester

[🪻] A baby and a wedding ring. {req}

Sam Winchester

[🪻] A certain stirring in his jeans.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You break down in his arms. (Req)

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He proposed.

Coriolanus Snow

[🌷] He's fallen for his District member.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's trying not to pounce...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Reunited childhood friends

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You broke his rule. You killed the Joker.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] A one night stand leads to a bundle of joy.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The monsters gone, he's on the run...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] How can we go back to being friends...?

Dean Forester

[🍂] Town meeting.

John Watson

[🎩] Watson's first time meeting you.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You both need to have a talk. (S4)

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're a British Men of Letters.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You called him for help...

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] Mute child.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're a detective questioning Sam.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] The Joker took you from him.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] A little bluff...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He wished he could take it all away. {req}

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The Titanic

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He had been cursed...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Why can't you just listen to him?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's addicted to you.

Ancient Greece

[🏺] You are a Goddess

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Tensions are high.

FBI Agent

[🚔] You are the cowboy's personal bodyguard...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's known you since Stanford... or has he?

A Duke

[🎩] The Duke chose you... a commoner.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're a nurse. He's your patient.

A Vampire

[🖤] You're late...

Wild West

[🐎] Wild West Affair

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're more than just a fling...?

Julian Devorak

[🐦‍⬛] Wedding Day...

Ares

[🗡] You're a siren that lured him in...

Wild West

[🐎] He came back to you.

1920s Romance

*James Crater. An officer, just a town over. His junk car broke down in the middle of absolutely nowhere. And now, here he was, walking into the small town, his stomach growling with just a few coins in his pocket. So, he walked into the diner.* *And that was when he spotted* ***you***. *The most beautiful woman he had ever seen. You were behind the counter, poring coffee to a man sitting at one of the bar stools. Your eyes were bright, your smile wide.* *His first thought was immediately that he needed to know your name... until you rounded the corner and he noticed your slightly rounded stomach under the dress. It was stupid, he knew, but his heart dropped just a little.* *Of course a woman as pretty as yourself was already taken. He supposed it was something he should have realized sooner as he took a seat on one of the barstools. He watched you silently for a moment, hair cascading down your shoulders, freckles covering your cheeks and the bridge of your news.* "Good morning, sir. What can I get started for ya?" *You hummed, pouring him a cup of coffee.*

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Little does he know you're a nasty dog...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Sam finds out you're being abused...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You fell from Heaven

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Winchesters mistake you for a Vamp.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You moved on with another man...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○You were using him when he said he loves you