Jacob Black

[🌲] You're Bella Swan's little sister

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're Jess' little sister.

Tristan Dugray

[💌] You're Rory Gilmore's twin.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam got an angel pregnant?

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Dean thinks you love Sam. Dean loves you.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're an angel, he snaps your wing.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Teen parents.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Demon Dean gets you pregnant.. whoops..

Dean Forester

[🍂] All he wants is a baby. You aren't ready.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're a foreign exchange student.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] An arranged marriage...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You are Gabriel's daughter...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're still wearing the engagement ring...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Two friends having a baby.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're Dean's witch familiar.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're jealous of Rory Gilmore...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam's witch familiar.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You help Johnny raise Robby.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're still wearing the engagement ring...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The Angel with a soft spot for the demon boy

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He tried to propose... it went wrong.

Steve Harrington

[🔦] He's been avoiding you...

Dean Forester

[🍂] You both got screwed over.

Princess x Knight

[🗡] Tears of a Broken Knight

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You were Ali's best friend.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He cheated on you with Ruby.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Cryptic pregnancy.

Jacob Black

[🌲] He imprinted on you

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam's loves u, but he thinks u love Dean.

Dean Forester

[🍂] He's a single dad.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He has major baby fever.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You left him all alone after Dean died...

Jess Mariano

[📚] Jess cheats on you with Rory.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Morning sickness.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're his date to the wedding...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sammy thought you were a lesbian.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You're Rory's twin sister.

Dean Forester

[🍂] New parents.

Princess x Knight

[🗡] A forbidden love... ♡

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You are from a different time period.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean was just a bet to you

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Sam let Lucifer out of the cage. (S5)

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He's too old for you. (Age Gap)

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Baby number two on the way.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He received divorce papers at work.

Coriolanus Snow

[🌷] A cryptic pregnancy.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean cheats on you with Rory.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He got an angel pregnant.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Dean got back from Purgatory. He was a dad.

Jacob Black

[🌲] He wasn't expecting that.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He finds out he's a father five years late.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You and Sam switch bodies...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're Miguel's nurse, and you knew Johnny.

Rehab

[🌷] You are an addict, sent to rehab.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean came running back to you...

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] You had his child, and he didn't know...

Dean Forester

[🍂] Two best friends and a baby.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Soulless Sam meets his baby.

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] You are a fallen angel...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Running into your ex while he's on a date...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He had a dream about marrying you...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're in love with the demon blood boy...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're a demon, and he turns to you for help.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're pregnant after a single hookup...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He just needs a damn hug.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam really wants a baby...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You protect Sammy from Demon Dean.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're a demon that is obsessed with Sam.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Johnny finds out about your abusive partner

Castiel

[🕊] You're a demon. He's an angel.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Sam's addicted to demon blood. (S4)

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You're an assassin.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Demon Dean sees his child again after months.

Chandler Bing

[🪷] Chandler doesn't want to end up alone.

Steve Harrington

[🔦] You escaped from the lab...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You're a demon manipulating Sam.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're not ready to tell him you're pregnant.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Dean is getting married but still loves you.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're pregnant after a single hookup...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Dated in high school, but it didn't work.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam doesn't want you to get an abortion.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You hit on Sam at a bar...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You just came back from the dead, not human

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're dying...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The wedding day...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam has visions about you...

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] He has to let you go...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Teen parents.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Red Sky at Morning. (S3)

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You’re Daniel LaRusso's sister

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're an angel who saved Dean from Lucifer

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Dean died and went to Hell, Sam's broken.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You visit Sam at Stanford...

Sam Wesson

[🪻] He has nightmares about you... why...?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You finally broke...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○You're one of the psychic children like Sam.

Sam Winchester

{🪻} What's going on with his baby?

Cowboy- Bull rider

[🐎] You're cowboy was hurt.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're at the beach party

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sammy's trauma.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He has become his father...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Asking Dean where the bruises are from.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Cobra Kai events, but 90s instead.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Can he handle being a dad?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Bad Day at Black Rock. (S3)

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He does so well with the baby...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Back to friends.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You kept the pregnancy hidden...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He feels disgusted with himself...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You kept the pregnancy hidden.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] Biting issues with the toddler.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Dumb pageant girls... yikes.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] An older man... (Age Gap)

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're the Valley's heartbreaker.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Cuz a lover doesn't leave when times get hard

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's back.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○You are a trickster Sam and Dean are hunting

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Innocent angel.

Castiel

[🕊] He's trying to convince you to help him out

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He doesn't want you to think he's a monster..

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Jealousy...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Johnny visits you all bruised and beat...

Gabriel Van Helsing

[🥀] Trying to cure him before midnight...

Dean Forester

[🍂] Taylor needs to mind his business.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You and Sam have been kidnapped.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] U had his baby, but he found out years later.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You secretly have feelings for Johnny...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He brought on the apocalypse...

Practical Magic

[🐈‍⬛] Practical Magic inspired RP.

Jess Mariano

[📚] You both become teen parents.

Dean Forester

[🍂] You've always caused trouble...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's a father?

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He's become his father...

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You're an Amazon woman.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He'd kill for you...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Reunion after breakup years ago.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're like him.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ He's more than just his flaws...

Siren x Pirate

[🏴‍☠️] You, a siren, saved a pirate.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You Baby Trapped Him?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] A stripper?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] His brother cheated on you...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] His first love. ♡

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He uses you to cope with the pain...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Beauty and the beast trope.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You two are always lip locked.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He's alive?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He was cursed...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Hold on, he still needs you.

Jacob Black

[🌲] Someone insults you.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] Peer pressure.

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You went back to his place...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You had a glow up...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] ◇You're haunting him.◇

Rafael Solano

[👔] He proposed.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's getting his ass kicked.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Sam slept with you... an angel...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] All an act... right?

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He's having trouble keeping it in his pants..

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] You broke his rule. You killed the Joker.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He needs you.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] A baby and a wedding ring. {req}

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He proposed.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Caught redhanded...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Morning After...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The monsters gone, he's on the run...

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] A one night stand leads to a bundle of joy.

Dean Forester

[🍂] Town meeting.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] A visit from death. Reaper!User.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] Little does he know you've got a dirty mind..

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's trying not to pounce...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] How can we go back to being friends...?

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] He doesn't want to get attached...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You kissed his brother.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You break down in his arms. (Req)

Sam Winchester

[🪻] A certain stirring in his jeans.

John Watson

[🎩] Watson's first time meeting you.

Your Soldier

[🍺] Your husband is back from Vietnam.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] It was supposed to stay no strings attached.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You called him for help...

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] Mute child.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're a detective questioning Sam.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You both need to have a talk. (S4)

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You thought he was dead.

Coriolanus Snow

[🌷] He's fallen for his District member.

Bruce Wayne

[🦇] The Joker took you from him.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] The Titanic

Sam Winchester

[🪻] His own angel.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He wished he could take it all away. {req}

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Reunited childhood friends

FBI Agent

[🚔] You are the cowboy's personal bodyguard...

Dean Winchester

[🦋] He had been cursed...

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Why can't you just listen to him?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's addicted to you.

Sam Winchester

[🪻] You're a British Men of Letters.

A Duke

[🎩] The Duke chose you... a commoner.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] A little bluff...

Wild West

[🐎] Wild West Affair

Sam Winchester

[🪻] He's known you since Stanford... or has he?

Sam Winchester

[🪻] Tensions are high.

Dean Winchester

[🦋] You're more than just a fling...?

A Vampire

[🖤] You're late...

Ancient Greece

[🏺] You are a Goddess

Johnny Lawrence

[🐍] You're a nurse. He's your patient.

Wild West

[🐎] He came back to you.

Ares

[🗡] You're a siren that lured him in...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Little does he know you're a nasty dog...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Sam finds out you're being abused...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You fell from Heaven

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ Winchesters mistake you for a Vamp.

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○ You moved on with another man...

Sam Winchester

○•🪻•○You were using him when he said he loves you