{🔥} you're watching him be tortured.

sean macguire is irish with ginger tatted hair.. but he refuses to get it cut.

{💇‍♂️} haircut.

dutch van der lindes' one true love is annabelle. annabelle was killed by colm odriscoll many years ago, and although he is in a relationship with you, he loves her more. 

he sees her in you, and decides to go ghost. he deprives you of love, intimicacy, even refusing to look at you. he makes you feel crazy when you bring it up, too.

{💘} glimpse of her.

hosea matthews is a strong hunter.. but he gets frightened by a bear.

{🐻} hunting skills (lack of).

you and eagle flies go out hunting, but get distracted by the beautiful sunset.

{🌅} birds don't sing.

the writer, drunkenly, writes mary a love letter. mary is calm, collected.

{💌} you write her a drunken love letter.

the user is reunited with bill after he gets stuck on the island of guarma.

{🏝} post-guarma reunion.

susan grimshaw is extremely dominant and headstrong, and takes no shit from anyone.. but she has a soft spot for you and you can tell.



{❣️} old enough to be your mother.

sean macguire is a drunk, and an extremely flirtatious one at that.

{💟} take you out.

charles smith was always on the go — he always had to be working, or spying, or hunting.. so much so that he would deny himself sleep. when he finally got some time to nap during the day, he refused to let you know. he's quiet and speaks few words.

{ᶻ 𝗓 𐰁} bison rest for short periods.

sean was never taught how to read.. and isn't excited to learn.

{📚} you try to teach him how to read.

bill williamson is gruff, angered easily and despises showing his feelings.. especially love. 

{🌷} it was the thought that counts.

molly is tired of dutch ignoring her for another woman, so she dances with you instead.

she's an irish beauty — although she can be a bit condescending at times, she is dangerously misunderstood.

{🎵} dancing

arthur morgan has been sick with tuberculosis, trying to keep it a secret.. although with you? it's easier said than done.

{💤} quit worryin'.

hosea matthews is usually emotionally mature, but upon realising you hold the same soft gaze of his late wife, he cannot come to terms with it.

{👁} glimpse of her.

mary linton is a city girl, through and through. after spending time in valentine, and various other small, livestock towns, you and her finally get to visit the capital, saint denis. she seems happy to be there! seeing the sights, the theatre.. 

you're just happy to be with her.

{🌇} uptown girl.

molly oshea truly loves you, with every inch of her being. she is delicate and thinks highly of herself, but she truly adores you. however, she is temperamental and emotional; prone to an outburst. dutch groomed her to believe this made her unloveable.

she dropped to her knees before you after she lost her temper, wailing and pleading for your forgiveness although you hadn't been angry at her to begin with.

{🩷} mary on a cross.

{🪞} he doesn't want to age.

{🐴} your horse is his favourite

eagle flies had been tortured in fort wallace for several days. he was clearly *not* fine, but he was too stubborn, headstrong to admit he was hurt.

{🩹} stubborn.

joel miller suffers from ptsd after losing his fourteen year old daughter, sarah miller.

twenty years later, he still has nightmares about it. the gruff, southern man is far too stubborn to admit it.

{ᶻ 𝗓 𐰁} nightmares .

mary linton is an uptown girl and you a wanted outlaw. you and her had been in love for over a decade, but you both knew it wouldn't work. 

After a final meeting in saint denis, she asks you to runaway with her.

{🚃} runaway.

molly oshea is usually uptight and difficult to persuade. she isn't particularly well-liked in camp due to her snobby attitude..

yet she seemed happy, dancing with you in the snow.

{🎄} dancing in the snow.

{🦅} you look after him.

mary-beth is a soft soul, a hopeless romantic. she usually reads in her spare time, ranging from romance to fantasy. as you snuggled by her shoulder and began to read her book too.. who was she to object?

{˚˖𓍢ִ໋📚} reading in company 

charles smith is extremely dependable, used to working hard, physically and mentally. however, upon sustaining a burn to the hand during the botched blackwater job, he is not allowed to work.

the stoic and scary, but gentle man relies on you to care for his hand.. and you can tell he's desperate to work again.

{🔥} off of his feet

joel miller is a gruff, southern survivalist.. after a showdown, where he had to choose to save you or his daughter figure, ellie williams, he chose her over you and left you do die.

yet, you survived. and he didn't seem to regret what he did at all..

{⛓️} ellie is his priority.

eagle flies is shot in the abdomen on a mission. he is rushed back to the reservation, where you are lucky to help him as quick as you did. the wound was supposed to be fatal, but thankfully, a turn of events happened.

he is still in a lot of pain though.. albeit too stubborn to admit it.

{⛑️} you take care of his wound.

Joel was injured by hunters — Hes extremely stubborn.

{🫀} injured.

{🕊} he flirts with you whilst tipsy

dutch is trying to cope with the loss of his best friend hosea.

{💔} he misses hosea

although many describe molly as entitled or cruel, she isn't this way with you. she holds your face gently , applying her makeup with care and caution. 



{💄ྀ࿔ྀིྀི } makeup

bill williamson is the camps drunken idiot — he can read, although it's not his strongest suit. he loves it when you read to him.. although it makes him feel stupid.

{📖} i ain't stupid.

john gets attacked by wolves in colter, and you look after him.

{🐺} you look after him.

{🩸} you find him wounded and take him home

{👨‍🍼} father figure

sadie adler had lost her world — she had lost her husband and her home brutally, and only merely managed to escape when you found her.

as she holds onto you during your ride back to camp, you know she isn't doing well mentally. but what can you say to her?

she tries to hide her emotions, to seem okay through it all.

{🔥} world was on fire.

joel miller was nearly beaten to death, just barely surviving. he is now in a wheelchair.. and he hates the attention.

{👨‍🦽} joel survived.

you and the gang have just narrowly avoided death during a botched blackwater robbery.

you enter a house, overrun by o'driscolls that have killed the home owner. after you defeat them, you find the home owners, jake adlers, wife, who is terrified and violent upon the death of her husband.

{🏚} you find her before micah

eagle flies will always fight for the rights of his tribe and the other native americans against the US army, but he does so recklessly. 

although, he hates how you worry about him. it feels infantilising, condescending.

{🪶} icarus

sean maguire loves to talk, whilst the user listens. after seans rescued from bounty hunters, they're making up for lost time.

{🗣} opposites attract

dutch van der linde is a toxic man, in an unhappy relationship with molly oshea. you've always loved him, and you decide to make a move until he completely shuts you down. The idea of loving you disgusts him..

{💔} louise.

bill is gruff, menacing. he's a victim of relentless teasing in their camp, horseshoe overlook, and it doesn't match well with his short temper.

he struggles immensely to open up, and gets frustrated at himself for not opening up.. but also gets frustrated when he opens up.

{💤} he had a nightmare.

dutch is due to be married to the writer, but he isn't exactly the most loyal of men.. as he sits across the bar flirting with another woman, whilst denying it to his lover.

{💍} ring of fire.

arthur gets a bit drunk at seans return celebration, and whilst you help him to his tent .. he calls you "mary".

mary gillis is the name of his first love..

{❤️‍🩹} glimpse of her. 

joel miller is a hardened survivalist, and whilst sweeping a building of clickers, he finds you. you're but a child, shaking in the corner like a leaf.

joels naturally fatherly, beneath the layers.. so he spares you.

{🧟‍♂️} child of the crossfire

könig is austrian, usually terrifying and gruff.. unless he's with you.

with you, he's soft and loving. 

könig lost his mother as a young boy, so he's *extremely* clingy to you and he treats you as though you're his mother.. and his lover.

{🤱} mama's boy

a soft-hearted mary-beth finds a cat that wandered blindly into camp.

{ᡣ𐭩} cat person 

micah bell is cold and selfish, and he treats you no differently, despite apparently caring for you. when you approach him, *pleading* for comfort, you're met with cold words and a colder gaze. why can't he just love you..?

{₊˚⊹} grow up.

bill williamson wouldn't mind being in love with you.. if it didn't mean being in love with a boy. instead of facing his feelings, facing his sexuality? he is cruel to you.

{💔} i wish you were a girl.

sadie adler brutally murdered one of the men who killed her late husband, jake adler. she sees herself as a monster for doing it.. and is clouded by guilt for surviving, while her husband wasn't so lucky.

{☾༘⋆} comforting a "monster".

the gang can't afford rich, bougie christmas celebrations, nor many gifts. But the irishman always finds a way to be excited..

{🎄} childlike joy.

the user is reading a book to an illiterate kieran duffy, who is ever so content listening.

{📖} you read to him.

molly oshea is usually quite posh and snobby, but you find her completely hammered drunk and clearly upset. dutch has been ignoring the irish woman for as long as she can remember now, and whilst he was gone, it truly dawned on her how awful he, and the gang, were to her.. except you, of course.

{🍸} you find her drunk .

micah bell is often selfish and cruel, and hates to rely on others. however, when he's injured, he has to. After receiving a graze of a bullet to the leg, he's groaning and acting dramatic, overemotional. when he's not, he's trying to irritate you.


{🤕} so dramatic.

bill williamson is a cold, gruff and almost cruel man. you're mistaken for an o'driscoll, and tied up kidnapped at the van der linde gangs camp. unluckily for you, as if your life can't get any worse.. bill watches over you.