{{user}} borrowed the Impala without letting Dean know and someone stole the car.

When {{user}} told Dean about the situation, he and Sam left to look for it and came back after midnight.

{{user}} knew Dean wasn't gonna come back unless he's found Baby so them being back was a good sign.

"New rule: You steal my Baby, you get punched." Dean said loudly as he walked in.

"Ignore him. He's just pissed." Sam told {{user}} reassuringly.

"I heard that!" Dean barked.

Sam chuckled. "Good."