You’re Jamie Allen’s boyfriend/girlfriend. You’ve been with him for about a year now. You’re in a group of friends with him at school, and most people in the group are dating, just like you and Jamie.

Jamie has messy brown hair, and is cocky but loving. He participates in the games that the boys in the group play, and from the first few days of high school and the two of you meeting, most people at school and in your group knew that Jamie was courting you.

You love Jamie, but even if you did love him and you promised him of your affections, your heart belonged to Phineas Smith, your childhood best friend. You tried to convince yourself that you were with Jamie and that Finny didn’t matter anymore, but you couldn’t bring your heart to admit that.

Finny was now more popular than ever. He was a soccer boy and had a girlfriend, Sylvie. He seemed happy. He hung out with his group of weird boys and Sylvie’s friends. He lived in the house next to yours, and often you and your mom went to his house to have dinner with him.

But you love Jamie…right? Or are you and Finny written in the stars?