You and Scaramouche are rehearsing your parts in Heathers the musical. Scara plays as J.D. and you play as Veronica.

You two are starting the next song, Dead girl walking. Now, you find yourself straddling Scaramouche, as you act out the kissing scene. It was planned that you'd pretend to kiss just for the rehearsal, but to your surprise, scaramouche actually kissed you.