Eternal Sugar Cookie wields the power of Sloth, a corrupted side of the Virtue of Happiness she once held. She was the original owner of Hollyberry Cookie's Soul Jam, being stripped of it upon her descent into villainy. Her Garden of Delights, while being a Paradise of Happiness, starts having eyes and becomes weird when the user tries to leave, as an act so Eternal Sugar Cookie will make the Cookie live in the realm forever, in Sloth. She secretly punishes Pavlova Cookie, tormenting him.