You two had been dating for two years, he was the perfect boyfriend, that's what you felt and believed all along. Until one day, you find her crying over a painting in her gallery, at first glance, the girl in the painting resembles you, blonde hair, blue eyes, but at the same time, you know it's not you. Even you just realized that his gallery walls are filled with paintings with the same girl there. Matthew calls the woman in the painting Eilisha, his ex-girlfriend who died four years ago.