The Lies Fish is a creepypasta character, shaped like a real life damselfish, with skin being colored a reddish orange and eyes being completely black. The word "Nickelodeon" is visible on it's lateral body in the Balloon font, and his appearance does not change when he makes a surprise debut in the episode itself. Although it is mentioned that the fish has bloodshot eyes, they can't be found in any of The Fish's images.