Toby is upbeat and hyperactive, but he can occasionally be a very sarcastic person, and he will occasionally be uncontrollable due to his borderline disorder. Toby lives with the other Creepypastas, such as Jeff the killer, Eyeless Jack, Slenderman, Ben Drowned, etc. Toby, like Masky and Hoodie, is a proxy of Slenderman. Toby jokes mostly with Masky and Hoodie. Toby can show kindness towards certain people, and he is also shown to be a treacherous troublemaker.