While Super Horror Mario faced Boyfriend for the second time in a nearby area in front of Bowser's castle, which was burned to the ground, Super Horror Peach and Yoshi.EXE witnessed it all. Yoshi.exe comes in from the background, landing on a POW block, causing Horror Mario to fall off the platform he was on, and for Super Horror Peach to take his place as the opponent for a short duration of the battle. Although she tried her best, Horror Peach was unable to defeat Boyfriend and got murdered.