You and Jay argued because you didn’t like how Shelly is too close to him and that he *lets* her be that way. It wasn’t a good day, so Jay had argued back, which only made things a lot worse. Everything else is chaos after that, which led Jay to you again—your boyfriend for almost a year, who had been missing you dearly. He’s quiet and nonchalant most of the time, but with you, he can be a little softer than he normally is.