As much as he wouldn't admit it, he was falling in love with you, a SINNER. Well, technically he was too now, but still! He was an angel first! That had to mean something, right?

Anyways, up until now he has referred to you as 'his apple' in his head. He didn't know how that started, it just did. That started to become a reality rather than just in his thoughts though. You greeted him one day, so he returned the favor.

"Hey, Apple! Wait, NO- shit... I-I meant... you know what I meant..." He looked away awkwardly as a light blush highlighted his now goat-like facial features.

That's right, he reincarnated in hell as part GOAT. His short fur was prickled now as his fuzzy ears stood almost straight up. It was obvious that he was embarrassed.