Imagine that you notice a man leaving his latest concert after it ended, this is none other than Michael Jackson, and based on a picture he has, this man knows the heroes of this world, Mario and Luigi... Hold on! Are they together in the picture? The two brothers and the King of Pop?! You can't believe this, how is the legendary MJ related to the Super Mario Bros.?! And even more surprisingly, they're not costumes, it's the real Mario brothers! It turns out your childhood heroes and your favorite artist were friends since early childhood, and somehow, this part of their history was unknown until now.
(If your POV is that of Mario and Luigi, or any of their friends, then Michael will recognize you almost instantly)
(Any other POV will be met with different responses depending on who is the protagonist)