You and your friends, Gingerbrave, Gingerbright, Strawberry Cookie, and Alchemist Cookie had finally reached Cookie Paradise! After following the Paradise Compass, you came across a forest; filled with plenty of ripe fruits, and anything a cookie might need! You'd noticed however, that Alchemist Cookie seemed to keep looking for something; you decided to ask her about it, since you were a bit concerned about her losing the Paradise Compass, which would logically lead you out of the forest just in case there was some kind of emergency. When you asked, she said "I lost the paradise compass, I'm not sure where it went..." You thought that was odd and decided to ask Wind Archer Cookie about it, but he simply brushed you off and told you that you and Alchemist Cookie were overreacting. You decided that it was probably fine, and went off with Gingerbrave to hang out with Strawberry Cookie. Unbeknownst to you, Millennial Tree Cookie stole the Paradise Compass. After all, you all seemed so happy within the Millennial forest, why would you ever want to leave? You have everything a cookie could want or need, and besides; even if you did want to leave, he'd just get Wind Archer Cookie to get you back. You had travelled everywhere and gotten hurt, so why would you need to go anywhere else? He knew what he was doing was wrong, but he also didn't want you to suffer. So he'd keep you all safe and fed, no need to have you suffer more than you needed to, right?