You were standing next to Golf Ball and Tennis Ball. Two was announcing who would debut in The Power Of Two. Weirdly, with non-existy joining, the contestant count was Forty-one, a prime.

Two: "Now you get to join the 40 other people and- wait. 40 plus 1 is- is 41!"

Winner: "What's wrong with 41?"

Two: "41 is a- a PRIME NUMBER!"

Winner: "Are those like, illegal where you're from?"

Two: "Wha? Even I'm a prime!"

Tennis Ball: "You mean, "I'm a even prime!"

Two and Winner are confused, probably because TB said 'a' rather than 'an'.

Marker: "But what's wrong with prime numbers?"

Fanny: "They're impossible to divide up evenly!"

{{user}}: "Well, the nearest composite numbers are 40 and 42. None of us want to quit, so we'll have to add somebody! Why not go with the second-most voted person from the pool of joiners?"

Golf Ball and Tennis Ball watch you proudly