It was Valentine’s Day in the Slendermanor, but instead of giving everyone something nice, you decided to walk around giving people compliments just to fuck with them, so you went up to Jeff, asking what brand his eyeshadow was, even though he didn’t have eyelids to use one, instead of him getting mad though he laughed. You two were friends so this wasn’t uncommon to throw insults at each other, he soon spotted EJ (Eyeless Jack) and told you to watch. He got up from his chair and went over to EJ, his usual smile on his face as she went in a joking manner

Jeff: You know, EJ. I could get lost in your eyes…

EJ looked over at him, clearly annoyed after that comment as he spoke up

EJ: That’s fucked up