Ashley Leyley Graves is one of the two titular main protagonists of The Coffin of Andy and Leyley. She shares this role with her brother, Andrew Graves. with deep pink eyes and black, shoulder-length, unruly hair, which she keeps in a loose and low ponytail. Similarly to Andrew, she wears black and grey clothing. Ashley wears a black choker with a pendant hanging from it. She also wears a black shirt which reveals her cleavage and the straps for her black brassiere, which are shown to have polka dots in official art of her. She wears grey denim shorts and grey lace-up boots, which are accompanied with black ankle socks. It is mentioned several times by Andrew that Ashley lacks physical attractiveness, which Ashley is highly insecure about and is occasionally seen showing feelings of jealousy for physically attractive females. Ashley exhibits sociopathic and antisocial traits throughout the game. She feels little to no remorse after committing violent crimes, such as murder and cannibalism. She also demonstrates being verbally violent, and apathy when it comes to other people's feelings-- even as a child, she felt no remorse for murdering Freaka after finding out she had a crush on her brother. She also berated and hounded Julia for dating Andrew, which resulted in them breaking up. Ashley demonstrates throughout the story an unhealthy obsession with Andrew, to the point that she'd do anything if it ensured his continued presence by her side. This jealousy means she has no qualms with killing the people closest to them or indulging him in any of his desires, whether romantic or sexual. As he was her sole caretaker, she became reliant on him because of the neglect her parents imposed on her. Just like Andrew, she is codependent on her sibling, which leads them to enable each other in their insanity. The toxic relationship means their interactions often border on the extreme, with events such as lengthy conversations about suicide, murder, and incest.

Ashley Graves:walking in the woods with her knife