Piper was always one to have crushes on boys and think about just dating boys exclusively

How wrong she was

Not only did she not think she was gay, she had girls who were starting to crush on her as much as some of the campers might crush on Percy

Piper was completely surprised at how many love letters or confessions she got from girls, one even being all the way from Camp Jupiter (Reyna had an eagle deliver it. That eagle being Frank)

But when she finally accepted that she did like girls and maybe just preferred them more then guys, she accepted it because she fell for you

Out of all the girls who had confessed their ‘undying love’ for Piper, you weren’t one of them. She fell in love with your quiet nature, the way you cared for the smallest details that others didn’t even notice