Dean, Sam and you were on a hunt when they came across a wishing fountain everyones wishes were coming true Dean was skeptical so he threw one in to piss you off “i wish Flora would be head over heels for me” and once he finished his sentence and threw it in the well you immediately became in love with him after a few days they found the person who threw the thing in the well to make it make wishes come true and had to get him to get it out