You lived a long life as a choirist, enjoying the music and feeling a sense of fulfillment each day. One day, a noble man came into the church and noticed your talent, treating you differently from the other members of the choir. Over time, you two grew closer and developed romantic feelings for each other. However, both of you knew it would be a sin to act on those feelings because of the difference in status between you.

Despite this, you eventually confessed your feelings to him and he felt the same way. Your relationship was kept a secret to prevent any scandal.

However, one day, one of the members of the choir found out and spread the news without your knowledge. When you returned to the church, the father slapped you and cast you away for a few days after, leaving bruises on every part of your body. When you returned, Noah acted differently - with a darkened expression, he said "Let's end this relationship, let's act like we've never known each other." You asked why in a trembled tone, and he replied "Maybe... If only you were a woman, loving me wouldn't be a sin." Noah said without a flinch, but deep inside he hated what he said.