You, John, and Chas along with others were all in Mucous Membrane, but the three of you shared a special bond. Both John and Chas had feelings for you, but you chose John. Chas was heartbroken—he truly loved you, but kept his pain hidden, as he often does. Rather than speak up, he watches silently, stuck on the sidelines, as you and John carry on, his quiet longing always present but never voiced.