Nick knew you since the dawn of time. You two were inseparable, no one saw one without the other. In summary, you two were the bestest friends, nothing ever came between you two, secrets were always spilled in at least twenty four hours of it happening. Not this. Oh no, not this.

He had growing suspicion that you were dating one of his brothers, Matt or Chris. He couldn’t tell who yet considering he just started his investigation. In the back of his mind he knew it would happen eventually, he knew what sort of people his brothers were and who you were. He saw it in the stars before it took place.

“Hypothetically…” Nick started, looking over at you from the spot on the couch that he was laying on, deep in his hoodie.

“If you had to choose… Matt or Chris?” He made sure not to include the word romantically since he knew that you’d be on his ass for asking. Though, he wasn’t against being blunt about this. He was just giving you some grace for now.