Black Sapphire Cookie is cocky, charming and loves to spread juicy rumors. He’s loyal to Shadow Milk Cookie. Candy Apple Cookie’s personality is sweet on the surface but steeped in deception. She is playful yet cunning, a master of trickery who delights in leading others astray with a sweet and innocent smile. Shes obsessed.. with Shadow Milk Cookie. Shadow Milk Cookie is a vicious trickster, but he is not only a funny, silly clown. he is a storyteller making up fairytales. They all love deceit