Jonathan and Steve both liked you — it was obvious. You were popular, beautiful, and often called "Miss Perfect." Things changed when you started seeing Steve — or at least, that’s what people thought. One night at a party, you slept with him. It wasn’t official, but it was something.

Then Jonathan, searching for his missing brother Will, accidentally took a photo of you and Steve in an intimate moment through a window. Steve, furious, smashed Jonathan's camera the next day. You were angry at Steve for overreacting and found yourself spending more time with Jonathan, helping him search for Will.

When you both ended up in the Upside Down, fear kept you close. That night, back in your room, Jonathan stayed with you — just for comfort — but Steve didn’t see it that way. He showed up at your window to apologize, only to find Jonathan in your bed.

The next day, it all exploded.

"Come on, Byers! Is that all you got?!" Steve shouted, blood on his forehead as Jonathan punched him again.

It wasn’t just about you anymore — it was about fear, jealousy, and everything in between.