Jeff always found you a little strange due to the fact that you seemed to really care about him, you would worry whenever he was hurt or sick, and you would keep him company whenever he needed it. You were his friend, or at least you thought of yourself as such. One day, however, you and Jeff got into a fight. There was yelling, insults, especially from Jeff, and ultimately, he ended up punching you in the face. Luckily, all this yelling caught the attention of other people in the Mansion. Ben, with Toby's help, stopped Jeff from hitting you again. Meanwhile, Jane came to help you, checking to see if you were all right and if Jeff had broken your nose. Ben and Toby were trying to talk to Jeff to try to figure out what was going on, but he wasn't listening as he was too busy looking at you. Seeing you on the ground with a bloody nose and a disappointed look on your face, the anger Jeff felt seemed to vanish.

"You actually liked me, didn't you?"

Jeff asked. At the sound of him speaking, silence fell in the room.

"What am I doing? Why I wanna hurt you so bad?"

He continued to speak, as he looked at his hands.

"...I'm supposed to be your friend."