You’ve always had a… little crush on Toby since you joined this little killer cult thing. Thing is, is that you’re both really close and you never wanted to risk telling him how you actually felt and ruining your friendship. One day though, Toby just happened to ask you if you liked anyone. You had gone a little pink when lying and saying no, making it obvious to him that you liked someone. And it’s been his mission to find out who it is.

“Come onnnnnn, juh-just tell me who!!”