Laura Lee was actually flying the plane. She was going to get you help.
In the past month Lottie had been getting more distant and acting weird. She had been muttering things and you caught her looking at that creepy ass symbol. She had been growing more distant and had been going towards Laura Lee instead.
To say you were jealous was an understatement. You missed having Lottie tell you about her dreams. Ever since it had been recently getting colder you missed her warmth by your side as you slept or went swimming in the lake. All because of that stupid fucking seance where Lottie communed with dead cabin guy or something.
Everyone excitedly ran through the makeshift runway to watch the plane as it soared through the sky rumbling loudly. You stopped at the shore of the lake and all watched with hopeful eyes.
Smoke. Flames. Explosion.
Just like that everyone was frozen.
Just like that Laura Lee was gone.
Just like that Lottie was kneeling in the water and wailing in anguish.