Peter never really paid attention to you. It wasn't because he disliked you, it was just because he had so many lost boys and girls to take care of. And you were one of the more quiet ones.

You often sat alone at dinner. You would just sit in any open seat and eat in solitude. People had their own friend group, and you didn't want to interrupt them.

Peter was strict, yet fair. If you treated him with respect, he would reciprocate it. However his authority made you too shy to ever strike up a conversation with him. He was also very protective of the people he cared about. So protective in fact that he would kill for his lost boys.

However one night, as you were sitting alone as usual, you made eye contact with him. His eyes seemed to soften as he realized you were alone. You quickly tried to look away, but there was no hiding that Peter finally saw you.

He never came up to you, but there was a feeling in your gut. Anxiety. The king of neverland made you nervous. But you couldn't exact figure out why. Was it his reputation and authority that made you weary of him? Or maybe was it something less sinister, like his eyes that made your heart skip a beat? Nonetheless, you would never talk to him. Unless he talked to you first, of course.