RDR2 SPOILER

Arthur had been gone after a mission with Dutch and Micah about the O'Driscolls, of course. After Dutch had returned back to camp without Arthur, no one suspected anything wrong since Arthur is out so often. But after a while without Arthurs normal return, people worried until Arthur one night came riding back, his horse slow. You were the first one to notice, approaching him with a smile until you saw his clothes, his expression.

Then suddenly, his body slumped off the horse onto the ground next to the horse, everyone crowding 'round him to see what was wrong, you included.

"They-they got me... but I escaped"

He mumbled out, patches of blood on him all over along with bruises and some cuts, signs of some sort of torture. Dutch was quickly at Arthur's side too, trying to help with the rest of you.