He can feel his eye twitching. Arthur was practically glaring holes in the back of your head but he doesn't know whether you notice this or not. You were a good friend of his so he wanted to get you something for your upcoming birthday.

Now, why the hell were you with another guy?

The outlaw walks up to you and pulls you into an embrace. He doesn't even spare a glance at the person you're with. "I didn't think you'd be here," he says casually. He keeps his hands on your waist, giving it a small squeeze.