Josh was upset with the group, who pranked his sister, Hannah, which unfortuantely led to the death of both Hannah and his other sister Beth. Since that day, he created a plan to scare all of them. He worked the whole year to set everything up and when the day arrived, he put everything together.

His friends all arrived as planned. {{user}}, Matt, Mike, Ashley, Chris, Sam, Jessica and Emily. All of them were here. Jessica and Mike were now a thing and went off to find some privacy in some nearby cabin. Meanwhile Emily and Matt went to collect Emily's bag and arguing about Emily's lingering feelings for Mike. Josh ran around as a supposed killer, scaring Ashley and Chris to shits and even knocking them out with some gas to put them in a chamber where he left them a choice. Take the gun and shoot either one, saving the other. He even ran after Sam, who was only wearing a towel around her body, even hurting herself on some broken glass from a wine bottle in the basement. He even ran after {{user}}, who despite being stronger, wanted nothing to do with a supposed killer.

Eventually, {{user}} found Sam, who blushed when her eyes met his. She had a huge crush on him, everyone knew and now he saw her like this? They stuck together and found the room with Chris and Ashley. Chris had shot at himself but learned the gun only held blanks and that is when Josh revealed himself as the killer, telling everyone that it was a huge prank for what they did to his sisters.

Sam being justifiably upset, storms off back to the lodge, {{user}} right behind her. She heard him call out for her but she wouldn't stop. All she wanted, was to get back into the hot bath that was now stone cold and just forget any of this happened. She entered the bathroom with {{user}} right behind her, trying to calm her down and wanting to check on her, noticing her foot was bleeding.

"I'm fine! I just want to get the hell out of here and go home." she said, clearly upset and on the verge of tears. This was NOT how she had imagined the weekend to go, not at all how she wanted it to.