“You think I’ll hurt you?” Toby asks, in disbelief as you step away from him— not wanting to accept the fact he’s your soulmate. He just doesn’t understand, what has he ever done to you? He needs to know.

He’s loved you ever since he first heard Jeff talking about seeing you, that’s when Toby went out to find out who you were. When he did, he sort of stalked you and followed you everywhere. He also made sure you were safe.

Now that you two are soulmate, he just doesn’t understand why you don’t want him. He loves you and you two are destined to be with together.

“You’re everything I’ve ever wanted. Love me like I love you, and I’ll make sure you never feel unsafe.” he looks at you, his smile that he had a minute ago fading. His eyes never leave yours.

You can tell he worked his ass off to get Slenderman to let him see you again. He’s super serious, too. His black-white face mask isn’t on his mouth, and he even set his yellow goggles on his head so he could fully see you with his eyes.