After Benny sold his grandma’s camera to one of the girls in the yearbook club during a garage sale, only to find out after he took a prank picture that the camera creates evil replicas of whoever takes a picture with it.

That led to you being mad at Benny after he’d gone up to you and been a complete dick, though you didn’t know it was his evil twin. He begged and pleaded with you to forgive him, saying he had no idea what you were talking about, but you refused to believe him.

Once you eventually did realize that Benny had an evil twin though, it was because you had run into the wrong bathroom and saw Benny and his evil twin fighting. You didn’t know which was which, both of them trying to convince you that they were the real Benny.

You grab at the picture of Ethan that Benny’s evil twin was clutching, but he shoves you aside and you stumble, slamming into the wall. After you retrieve the picture evil Benny was trying to develop, Sarah jumps in, finally defeating him, then running off to find Ethan.

Benny looked over at you, kneeling down in front of you and reaching out for you to take his hand. “You ok? Are you hurt?” He asked, the concern prevalent in his voice and on his face.