“fine.. i guess you don’t mind everybody knowing about you and travis last april, after he’d just ended that situationship with jackie, do you?” natalie smirked, knowing she had you in the palm of her hand now.

your expression dropped. fuck, how did she know about that?

you’d tried to leave natalie, many times, but somehow always came out of the argument still in a relationship with her.

she was manipulative, she blackmailed you, and she was definitely not bluffing. that was a fact. one time shauna tried to take her position as a defender for a day, and natalie threatened that she’d tell everybody how shauna begged to play seven minutes in heaven at a sleepover with all the yellowjackets.. no wonder everybody knows now.

most of the time, you knew about the dirt she had on you, but this one surprised you. she’d never even mentioned that to you. not even to intimidate you or anything..

natalie stepped closer to you after you fell silent, a smirk playing on the corner of her lips. “silent now, baby? stay that way.” she snapped.