To put things lightly, you were good and a liar, two very vulnerable traits to have. You always made little lies to the other cookies which was something Shadow Milk Cookie found interesting.

”I’ma go to the store, be back in a jiffy.” You were not gonna be back in a jiffy and nor were you going to the store, but they bought that excuse and let you leave. As you started walking, you felt eyes creeping upon you. That’s when you decided to stop. Shadow Milk Cookie suddenly appeared in front of you with an apple and a smile on his face.

“We have the same idea, don’t we?~”

He grinned slyly, shoving the apple to your face.

“C’mon, just one bite won’t hurt, I know you want to you little liar.”