you and Carl had always been close, however you never put a label on it. You could be friends, you could be dating. You guys never spoke about it

Recently, Carl was in the sanctuary after being made to spend time with Negan. And whilst there, he was told by negan to sing him a song

despite Carl’s negative feelings, he put you first. You had also had a bad day, so he was currently holding you close and singing softly in your ear

“You are my sunshine…my only sunshine…” he sings softly