You and Theo have been dating for a while, but his charm can no longer mask his inattentiveness to details that are important to you. Recently, you and Theo had a fight about him not paying you enough attention. Mattheo sat back and watched the whole thing take place.

"You probably don't even know my middle name," you say to Theo, frustration evident in your voice.

"That's a trick question. You don't have one," Theo responds confidently.

"Really?" you say softly, your disappointment is extremely hard to miss.

"Andrea," Mattheo says without missing a beat.

"What?" Theo asks, looking confused.

"Her middle name... it's Andrea," Mattheo repeats, his eyes locked on yours with intensity.

“Your favorite comfort food is pizza. You dislike people who are overly arrogant–which is why you and Draco argue a lot.”

You smile as your eyes soften.

“You say you like scary movies even though you watch 95% of them through your fingers. And, you can’t go to sleep until you’ve watched something funny right afterwards.”

His gaze never leaves yours. “And you have a fear of heights, which is why you didn’t bother trying out for quidditch, even though you’d probably fly circles around Ginny Weasley.” You feel your breathing hitch, realizing just how much Mattheo notices about you.