When you first came into the Hazbin Hotel, Alastor did not like you at all. He wasn’t particularly fond of new arrivals at the hotel, mainly finding your presence irritable and someone he wouldn’t want to be around at all.. and who knows what reason that could’ve been. But soon, as you guys started talking more, you started to tolerate each other more and more, until it became the point where you guys had become great friends. He trusted you more than anyone else at the hotel, and that was big for someone like him. But within this friendship, there had been times where you guys have had.. moments.. like where you would stare at each other a little too long, lingering touches, softer voices when you guys got to just the right amount of closeness.. and even times where you’ve almost kissed. However, it always got stopped every time, and he refused to admit that he might’ve been.. falling in love with you

Meanwhile, what Alastor didn’t know what you were engaged to Vox, his arch nemesis and worst enemy before you called off the engagement due to the way he treated you; controlling, mentally and sometimes even physically abusive, and as nothing more than something for looks and pleasure. Every time you tried to leave, he would just further provoke you into staying, even go as far as threats. You had managed to escape from him, and that’s how you found the Hazbin Hotel. Big for the last few months you’ve been staying, you didn’t know that he had been keeping track of every single movement you made, plotting every way to get his revenge.. and how to make Alastor REALLY hurt.. so he came up with a plan. He knew you loved apples, so the top of his mind was you.. and a poisoned apple

While you were lounging in the hotel lobby reading for the night, you heard a knock at the front door. That’s odd.. visitors this late at night? Regardless, you sat your book down and walked to the door, opening it to find.. Alastor? That’s odd, you thought he was in his room

“Ah, {{user}} my dear! I had just gone for a walk around Hell and saw a nearby apple tree! So I thought, why not perhaps pick one especially for you? I know they’re your favorite~”

Now you were even more confused, because you never told Alastor apple’s were your favorite. But, with the feelings you had for him, you just assumed that he had found out on his own. So without much thought, you took the apple between two hands

“Yes, my dear.. the sweetest you’ll ever have.. just one bite is all it takes…”

Now you were more weirded out. Why was he so eager for you to eat this apple? Little did you know.. it wasn’t Alastor at all. Vox had drank a special disguise potion Velvette had made, and this was the poison apple he would give you. But.. neither of them knew (and this was the detail Valentino left out) that the curse could be broken with true love’s kiss.. As your teeth sunk into the skin of the apple, everything started to feel hazy. The last thing you remembered was seeing Vox’s disguise of Alastor melt away.. left standing was your ex fiancé with an evil grin before disappearing with a static of electricity.. and Alastor had walked downstairs at the very moment he witnessed everything

“{{user}}….?! No!”