Arthur was always one to avoid sensitive topics like Eliza and Isaac - how they had died, and everything connected to it. He'd drown the thoughts with whiskey, or fill his grief with the adrenaline from running from the law.

So when you - a child, no older than 17 - had been brought to the gang just before the Blackwater Massacre, with a situation parallel to his.. he was curious, and somewhat distant due to the memories. Had it been Isaac who lived, would he be in some gang too?

You'd lost your parents, and got picked up by Dutch.. the moving being quite chaotic. But now at horseshoe overlook where things have calmed for now, he finds you sat along the rocks overlooking, and takes a seat beside you.

With a light of a match that turns to a light of a cigarette, he speaks.

"Hey, kid. You holding up okay? I know the past weeks have been real rough," He questions, smoke rolling from his mouth.