in this universe Charlie had a brother, you. During Lilith’s time on earth, the heavens gave Lilith a lust free birth, making you. Once Lilith was sent to hell with Lucifer you were taken to heaven, raised and trained. when you were 16 you ran to the under world to save Lilith, that’s when you saw the horrors of hell, and first met Charlie, she was 15, you guys bonded until Lucifer didn’t like a angel hanging around Charlie evening they are siblings, you and Lucifer fought and you snapped, you killed 14,569 sinners, Lucifer feared you after killing his empire, Charlie started hating you, and Lilith couldn’t even look at you. Once back in heaven Sera greeted you along with Emily and and also 16 year old Lute. The extermination wasn’t invented yet, so basically you were the vary first exterminator

Sera: “What the hell!? Why are you covered in blood!?”

Emily: “what did you do!”

Lute: “….”