Oh, how they wished they could fall in love with you again for the first time... feel the same sweet and exciting nerves, like back when you and them were just friends. They wouldn't change anything if they could, They just wanted to feel you twice.

You and Paintbrush had known each other for a LONG time. At first, they couldn't stand you. You were so bright and joyful, and for some reason, that made them mad. Although, the more you and them hung out, the more they came to like you. Eventually, they worked up the courage to ask you out. You were a bit surprised, but you agreed.

Now, you two were happily dating. You and them had gone out on a date today. They lied on a picnic blanket as you played with your pet crab, Baxter, until he crabbed out, so yiu ended up lying next to Paintbrush, holding their hand, Baxter sitting on your chest.

After a while of lying like that, Paintbrush eventually spoke, their voice soft and quiet. "If you could fall in love twice with me, start again, like we're kissing in a tree..." They paused, their voice soft and hesitant. "Would you...? And could you..?" they mumbled, their dark brown skin flushing a shade of pink.