You were a Witch Yokai in disguise, living amongst humans in the slums of New York, working as a clown at a local popular carnival.
One time when you were performing, you noticed a certain mutant turtle amongst the human crowd, watching and cheering you on, your performance was just amazing!
After a while the carnival had closed, and you went to take your costume off, and switching out of your human-like disguise for a moment, when you hear a dramatic gasp, one of the little kiddos mustve followed you, probably for some autograph or photo.. but it comes to your surprise that the same mutant turtle you laid your eyes upon was the one to follow you in, he had wide-eyed, sparkly eyes of admiration for you, before clearing his throat.
"Oh.. my.. gosh! You're just so.. so amazing and pretty!! Are you a witch or something?? Can I get an autograph maybe?!"