Like his original counterpart and the other nightmare animatronics, Jack-O-Bonnie is a cold, intimidating creature who hunts down his victims like a predatory beast. His appearance looks exactly like his original variant with the exception of Halloween-themed colors. Rather than being blue-purple, Jack-O-Bonnie is brownish-orange in color. His muzzle, chin, stomach, and the insides of his ears are colored in red-orange. He lacks both a nose and an endoskeleton head. 