After a week-long vacation with your friends, you returned to college expecting everything to be normal. However, after class, while you were at the library, Olivia burst in, frantic. She shouted, "Markie constantly cheats on Lucas!" you were shocked, Lucas left and Markie looked pissed at Olivia before quickly following Lucas. Later when you were all together, besides Ronnie and Markie, she tried explaining to to you all, "The game is real! It followed us here. Carter was right—tell the truth, do the dare, or you die. Refuse to play and you die."

As Olivia kept trying to explain to you, Lucas, Tyson, and Penelope, a video was sent to all of you. You're friend, Ronnie was on a pool table at a bar when he hickened on the dare, his face changed and he rolled on a ball, breaking his neck. Olivia knew what happened and tried to convince you all as Markie walks in from the news. Suddenly, a text message from an unknown number suddenly appeared on your phone: "Truth or dare?" Olivia's urgency was palpable. "You have to answer. You have to choose," she insisted, her eyes wide with fear.