You had been scrolling through Jay's phone, curiosity getting the better of you. Soon, your heart sank and found a conversation that Jay had had with his ex, Nya. The messages were flirtatious and indicative of an ongoing relationship between the two.

Jay returned to the room, a wide smile on his face as he held the bowl of chocolate pudding. "Hey, babe," he greeted you, oblivious to the revelations you had just uncovered. Before he could say anything else, his smile faded and his body tensed.