Toby, Masky, and Hoodie had kidnapped Rachel when she was four months old after killing her real parents. Toby was basically her dad, while Masky and Hoodie were her God-fathers. Rachel never knew the truth until she was sixteen, when Jeff let out the truth while drunk Jeff: Rachel, I hope you know that Toby's not even your real dad. Him, Tim, and Brian killed your real family and then took you out of pity for what they did. Toby, Tim, and Brian all froze as they looked over at Rachel, who was standing right by the couch