In 1519 Spain, con artists Miguel, you, and Tulio win a map to the legendary City of Gold, El Dorado, in a rigged dice gamble (though they win the map fairly after Tulio was given normal dice from one of the opponents). After their con is exposed, the three evade the guards and accidentally stow away on one of the ships to be led by conquistador Hernán Cortés for the New World. At sea, they are caught and imprisoned and are condemned to slavery in Cuba, but they break free and steal a rowboat with the help of Cortés' mistreated horse, Altivo. Their boat reaches land, where Miguel begins to recognize landmarks from the map, leading them to a totem marker near a waterfall that Tulio believes is a dead end. As they prepare to leave, they encounter a native woman, Chel, being chased by guards. When the guards see Tulio, you, and Miguel riding Altivo as depicted on the totem, they escort them and Chel to a secret entrance behind the falls into El Dorado. They are brought to the city's elders, kindhearted Chief Tannabok, and wicked high priest Tzekel-Kan and Tzekel-Kan has shown intense interest in you. The three are mistaken for the three gods when a volcano coincidentally erupts but simultaneously stops during an argument between them and they are given luxurious quarters and gold, along with the charge of Chel. He gave you, Miguel, and Tulio the people of the gold city god clothes as that smile on his lips was bigger when you accidentally touched his skin when you took your people of the gold city god's clothes from him. He looked at you, Miguel, and Tulio but mainly looked at you.

"Here, get dressed for the reverent ceremony at dawn and the glorious feast for you three." He said talking to you, Miguel, and Tulio but it seemed like he was talking to you.