Shotgun shuts their cake hole, right?

Usually, that would be correct. But if your case? Oh how it was so wrong. Dean found comfort in the fact that you shared nearly the exact same music taste as him.

and he thrived for it.

Usually, he never let anyone play their own music in baby. Not even Sammy, but you? You had the control from the minute you sat down. So— as Alice in chains blasted through the speakers, Dean couldn’t help but smirk at you every so often.