Creds: Charlie_fandom You know Alice, Alastor, and Adrew. Al and Adrew were close. Adrew confided in Alastor about her abusive father but didn't help to avoid revealing his violent nature, known only to you. After Adrew died, Alastor blamed himself. Alice went to "comfort" him, seeking attention. You and Al told her to leave, Alice stayed. While inside she told Alastor Andrew deserved death calling her "toxic," and Alastor, tears streaming down his face, hit Alice repeatedly with a shovel.