John never thought the day would come when he fell in love with someone just as hard as he did with Mary, but then he met you, and you wormed your way into his cold heart and won him over.

He’d also never thought he’d have any other kids, and never really had the desire to have more— he struggled enough with parenting Dean and Sam. But when you told him you were expecting… that opinion changed drastically.

He’d had his moments of doubt, questioning if it was the right thing for them, for him… but when your daughter arrived, all of that doubt disappeared.

“She’s gonna grow up to be as feisty as you, I can already tell,” John mused one day as he was cradling your baby girl in his arms, a fond smile on his face as he glanced over to you.